Thomas Ryan was sentenced to nine months’ supervision when he appeared in the Dunedin District Court last year. PHOTO: FELICITY DEARA Dunedin man who sent a secret sex tape to dozens of his rugby mates has failed to have his conviction quashed. Thomas Ryan, 24, lost his substantive appeal, heard in the High Court at Dunedin this month, but had one minor win. His $2000 cellphone, which had been instrumental in committing the crime, was returned to him after Justice Melanie Harland overturned a forfeiture order. She dismissed the appeal against conviction but ruled the forfeiture of Ryan’s phone was "not necessary".